How it happened
It should have been simple, really. A nice walk, a park, and dinner afterwards. Unfortunately, Josh has a way of taking simple ideas and tweaking them until they get more and more complex. That Thursday evening, they met in the Old City and made their way to the Kotel (the Western Wall). Some fast thinking and excuses of photographs allowed Josh to get Alexis down to the Kotel first, a necessity in order to take the roses through the security checkpoint without the guards looking through the bag in front of Alexis. After the Kotel, the two made their way out of the Old City towards Yemin Moshe. Supposedly, they were meeting a friend before dinner. Outside the old city, Josh gave the decoy rose. Little did Josh know, but by failing to answer the phone when he'd been at the jeweler's that morning, he'd managed to make Alexis suspicious, thus losing any chance of surprise. In Yemin Moshe, they found one of the parks had a random minstrel sitting out of sight, playing a guitar (not at all abnormal for Jerusalem parks, although this one happened to be an old friend of Josh's), and sat for a time. Under a beautiful starry night, in front of a view of the old city of Jerusalem, with a musician playing lecha dodi in the background, Josh got down on one knee and took out the second, real rose, an amethyst and silver necklace wrapped around the flower, and asked Alexis to marry him. After an indeterminably long silence, he asked again, at which point she realized that answering might be a good thing.
Josh's Engagement Statistics:
Number of roses involved: 2
Number of florists visited looking for the right roses: 3
Number of mailing containers butchered: 1
Number of poster tubes purchased after butchering mailing containers: 1
Number of decoys involved in proposing: 5
Surprise achieved (Y/N)? No. Silly precognitive women.
Number of stores visited looking for amethyst necklace: 25+
Number of cups of coffee consumed in the 6 hours prior to getting engaged: 4
Number of proposal plans discarded: 2327, +/- 5
Number of times I had to change the time for the dinner reservation at Gabriel's: 2
Number of days I waited before telling her that the random minstrel we heard playing in the park behind us was actually a friend of mine who she'd met the day before we got engaged: 2.5
Number of phones stolen after having been locked in Gabriel's coatroom: 1 (hers)
Bottles of champagne consumed thursday and friday: Only 2...
Hearing her say that she wants to marry me and spend the rest of her life with me? Priceless.